Comments on your lines, five scores, and what to do next.
Rubric Scored 0–5
Voice consistency 4 / 5 · Strong
Cliché avoidance 2 / 5 · Needs work
Stock phrases: “the fog of language barriers,” “chaos gave way to curiosity.”
Hook strength 4 / 5 · Strong
Personal specificity 2 / 5 · Needs work
You name the fix but never show it.
Structure 4 / 5 · Strong
Overall note
What you built that summer is the proof, and it gets one sentence. Cut the line about your approach and spend those words on the flashcards and what the toddlers did with them.
UC PIQ · 339 words Sample
Toddler English
“If they aren’t listening, find a way to speak their language.” My Humanities teacher left me with these words before unexpectedly abandoning my class mid-year in a global pandemic.
My younger self was puzzled by what these words meant. These parting words felt more cryptic than helpful–a riddle I wasn’t ready to solve.
1 Both sentences say you were puzzled. Keep one and get to the daycare sooner.
A few years later, during summer break, my parents hired a new teacher for our daycare center. Her struggles to control the chaos as the toddlers ran wild became the subject of their complaints at dinner.
It wasn’t until I was assigned the toddler room the next day that I introduced myself and learned her name, Ms.Feng. Listening for a few seconds, it clicked: the chaotic atmosphere wasn’t just noise– it was a cry for connection. The toddlers weren’t being understood because Ms.Feng didn’t speak their “toddler English,” and they, in turn, didn’t speak her Mandarin. I recognized that the toddlers’ “language” wasn’t just a mixture of thoughtless babbles and gestures but an attempt to bridge the verbal divide. The first step in leading is identifying the issue. The second is to fix it.
Evolving my approach, I immersed myself in the dilemma rather than observing from the sidelines. The rest of that summer, I spent my time in the daycare designing flashcards, implementing new activities, and pulling together a presentation that I presented to teachers and parents, navigating them through the fog of language barriers. By summer’s end, chaos gave way to curiosity, and Ms.Feng, the toddlers, and I spoke a shared language.
2 This tells me you got involved. Cut it and start with what you did.
3 Your fix, rushed into half a line. What was on the flashcards?
4 Says the same thing twice. What did you tell the parents?
5 Stock phrase. Show one thing a toddler did instead.
Leadership is not about being a class Vice-President, nor is it being elected for mayor. Had I relied on titles, I would’ve gotten no further than the line leader with a glittery sticker on their chest. Authentic leadership means recognizing a problem and stepping in with empathy and action. From toddlers with Ms.Feng, peers at Boys and Girls State, or countless others I’ve worked alongside, real change happens when you speak someone’s language. Maybe my teacher had been speaking mine all along.
6 Boys and Girls State first shows up here, in your last paragraph. Cut it or set it up earlier.
A real student’s draft. The comments, scores and note were written for this sample.
Get my free review